Cookies dipped in water are good and should be more common, amirite?

But....I don't dip cookies purely for the consistency. I dip them for the saturated milk taste AND consistency. The two are mutually exclusive for me. A soggy cookie with no milk flavor is entirely missing the purpose for me.

by macejkovictrema 4 months ago

Yes the consistency and flavor is key. Soggy cookies in milk reminds me cookies n cream!.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

i dip cookies in tea & coffee 😂😂

by Lacey30 4 months ago

Cookies in tea is elite. Could never get behind coffee, though. To me it just ruined a good biscuit and coffee

by Judah18 4 months ago

Cookies are generally dipped in typical pre ground filter coffee. Not some high quality freshly ground coffee.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I've only ever dipped it into instant coffee like Moccona or Robert Tim's, just never been a fan personally. But I can definitely see how people like it

by Judah18 4 months ago

Espresso is peak cookie dipping liquid. It has to be the right cookie though, not like a chocolate chip cookie. More like a biscotti.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I mean, some kinds of cookies pair well with the bitterness of coffee. But mostly the benefit of the coffe dip is the instant warming effect.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Water isn't tasteless. Clear does not equal tasteless.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

And even if it was tasteless, it would absolutely alter the taste of the biscuit cookie by diluting it.

by fritschzoila 4 months ago

This! Ugh. In my area there's so much chlorine in the water! It's definitely something you can taste, and I've even lived where there was so much you could smell it.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

thats crazy

by Familiar_Violinist 4 months ago

It sucks. Meanwhile, I have a friend in another state. When I go to visit them, I drink so much tap water because there's no chlorine in it. It's super clean tasting, and once it's iced down (colder the better for me,) it's so refreshing.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I think I'd rather have teeth than better tasting water, but that's just me I guess.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

That's fluoride, not chlorine. Fluoride is for teeth. Chlorine is used when water isn't clean enough. You don't taste fluoride like you do chlorine, either. And I would like to keep my teeth, too, but unfortunately, Sjögren's Syndrome is a thing.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

This truly reads like an alien trying to mimic human behavior and getting annoyed and confused by humanity.

by SeparateBug 4 months ago

I enjoy milk and coffee cookies too! I just add water to the list of acceptable things to dip cookies in lol

by Kklocko 4 months ago

We got you now alien!

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Is your fourth dipping option liquid nitrogen, alien?

by macejkovictrema 4 months ago

That's gross af

by carolyne29 4 months ago

I needed that laugh ty :)

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I'm also picturing you doing a Tim Tam Slam with unflavoured hot water, and yeah... a truly, truly unpopular take.

by fritschzoila 4 months ago

Soggy nilla wafers or soggy chip ahoys used to be so good as a kid!. I miss that nostalgia :( I swear they changed the taste the haven't been the same since. It sucks when it's not the same.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I dip cookies in coffee & milk FOR the flavor, I couldn't imagine dipping them in water

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Baileys Irish cream

by Sweaty_Story_8950 4 months ago

HEATHEN!!!! Awful...

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I used to dip them in hot tea, plain old water doesn't taste right to me but hot tea is good and it softens them up.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Jail

by Visual-Champion 4 months ago

How do you like to eat your cookies?. I couldn't ever dip them in plain water. I like mine with Milk and sometimes tea. Depends on what cookie it is tho.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Great unpopular take. I think it is highly psychological, one of the reasons I think cookie that is dipped in water seems wrong because when it happens by accident people are annoyed. Also, if you like crispy cookies, like most people, you will like coffee dipped ones for the taste, but if you only get the consistency and the idea it was dipped in water of all things, it will just trigger pretty irrational repulsion.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I have actually tried dipping an Oreo in water before, and it was surprisingly similar to dipping in milk. I haven't made it a habit but it's not gross as it sounds.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I like Oreos in water. Not ice cold water. Like room temp water. It facilitates easy eating. How else am I gonna down an entire stack of them?

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I've been doing this all my life and never hear the end of it from my friends and family

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I agree with this, I don't drink cookie crumb water 🤣 I toss it

by Kklocko 4 months ago

Most milk doesn't have a strong flavor anyway. I would never dip in just water but I think you have a point.

by Advanced-Solid-765 4 months ago

Cookies dipped in any kind of liquid are all equally gross. Sometimes I want cookies to be crunchy, sometimes chewy; never would I want them soggy.

by Mundane_Valuable489 4 months ago

I used to do cookies in apple juice. Loved it

by Anonymous 4 months ago

I could see this being good with certain kinds of cookies. Ginger snaps, for example.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Just looked this up. Very interesting! I'll have to try it soon.

by Kklocko 4 months ago

Do you drink the cookie water after? I think that is the make or break question

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Nope, toss it.

by Kklocko 4 months ago

Finally a decent unpopular opinion

by Anonymous 4 months ago

My name may, or may not be, Meeko.

by Kklocko 4 months ago

Finally someone agrees! Lactose and tolerant child me is fulfilled

by Over-House 4 months ago

And I'm not even lactose intolerant!

by Kklocko 4 months ago

Unfathomable.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

🤢

by Anonymous 4 months ago

huh?

by kendrickrippin 4 months ago

You monster!

by Anonymous 4 months ago

No no no no no no just no

by Anonymous 4 months ago

More curious to know what you do with the cookie tainted water.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Toss it. That would be like drinking backwash water 🤢

by Kklocko 4 months ago

That's the most wrong thing I have seen today.

by Anjalifriesen 4 months ago

Yeah, as others have said, eating soft/soggy cookies isn't the main appeal. A waterlogged cookie is just a waterlogged cookie.

by omalindgren 4 months ago

Are they good cookies? Or are we talking chips ahoy quality here, or even lower quality?

by Schimmeljunius 4 months ago

straight to jail

by Familiar_Violinist 4 months ago

What

by Anonymous 4 months ago

The only time I dip cookies is in almond, coconut or oat milk. Hot chocolate and tea is great. I dip cookies because I love not only the added flavor but the texture. It's a twofer!

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Who dips their cookies in soda?

by Anonymous 4 months ago

NO NO NO NO NO

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Wait... What do you put in your cereal?

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Milk. I don't really eat cereal anymore though. I did have it with water once at my grandma's house when I was 13 tho because she only had powdered milk and I've heard the horror stories and wasn't brave enough to try it.

by Kklocko 4 months ago

The thing you dip into is part of the experience. I want the taste of tea, milk, coffee that I use to dip my cookies.

by Anonymous 4 months ago

This is original

by Aggressive-Gur-4824 4 months ago

You're right about one thing, dipping in juice would be way worse

by Anonymous 4 months ago

🧐 curse all you lactose challenged people /s

by Anonymous 4 months ago

Eew lol

by Immediate-Key 4 months ago

People generally dip food in liquids because the flavors combine well, not simply because they want to eat wet food. Think of dipping a grilled cheese sandwich in tomato soup. This is done because the flavors of the sandwich and soup complement each other well, not because the person wants a wet sandwich. With cookies and milk the milk enhances the cookie, and then at the end you get a glass of milk that tastes a little bit like a cookie as well. Dipping a cookie in water helps neither the cookie nor the water.

by Anonymous 4 months ago